19 Action News|Cleveland, OH|Breaking News, Weather, ExclusivesBeard Bandits Exclusive: Is there a cult in Amish country?

Beard Bandits Exclusive: Is there a cult in Amish country?

Posted: Updated:
(WOIO) -

They're known as the beard bandits -- a group accused of terrorizing the Amish community by cutting the beards and hair of those who opposed their leader.

Sam Mullet is the man the FEDS say is behind the beard bandits. For the very first time someone from inside Sam Mullet's crazy world is speaking out exclusively to 19 Action News reporter Scott Taylor.

Sam Mullet's world, some call it a cult, exists on 800 acres in Bergholz, OH.  It's where he lives with his children and other followers.

"I think he has a way of brain washing you to do what he wants you to do," said Tonya Mullet.

Tonya Mullet, Sam's daughter-in-law, is speaking out for the very first time about what's it like to live in Sam Mullet's world. 

"I believe if he told somebody to go out and murder for him, they would do it," said Tonya Mullet.

Sam Mullet and six others including some of his own sons are now facing federal hate crimes.   Investigators say the group shaved the beards and cut the hair of Amish who refused to support Sam Mullet.
 
Tonya Mosley became Tonya Mullet in 1994 at the age of 16 when she married Sam Mullet's son, William.

She was quickly taught the way's of Sam's world.  

"They wanted me to forget I ever had any family out here," said Tonya Mullet.
 
Sam's world includes beatings and much worse according to Federal Court documents. Sam would have his follower's wives live with him in order to be counseled on how to be sexually satisfied in their marriages.

"He has the woman believing he's some God. He is sleeping with daughter-in-laws. He is sleeping with other women," said Tonya Mullet.
 
Investigators call Sam the leader of this community and members have to obey Sam. Tonya says if you didn't agree with Sam Mullet he would try and break you.

"They would put two chairs in the middle of the floor and have Bill and I on those chairs and have any where from 15 to 20 chairs in a circle around us and make us sit that way all night long," said Tonya Mullet.

Tonya left Sam's world over a disagreement about medical treatment for one of her and Williams' seven children. She admits to a criminal past including an OVI conviction and was once addicted to pain medication.

Tonya and William have split. He has the kids. William does not live on his father's compound and belongs to another church.  

Tonya says Sam also held people hostage in their own homes.

Even though she's out of Sam's world Tonya is still afraid of Sam Mullet. 19 Action News was able to get a message to Sam through his lawyer about Tonya's allegations. So far he hasn't responded but in the past he has said he's not part of a cult.  

"He is an evil man and I think he needs to be put away for a long time," said Tonya Mullet.

Tonya believes Sam and his followers on those 800 acres of land are capable of anything.  

"He said he had a lot of land and could do away with me and I would never be found," said Tonya Mullet.

Sam Mullet has not been found guilty of anything. He remains locked up and will be back in court on Wednesday, January 11th.

  • Local NewsLocal News

  • Wednesday, May 23 2012 6:26 PM EDT2012-05-23 22:26:58 GMT
    Who couldn't use some cash right now?  You may have some unclaimed cash we your name on it. Employees of the Ohio Division of Unclaimed Funds are in the 19 Action News Studios today to help you claim
    Who couldn't use some cash right now?  You may have some unclaimed cash we your name on it.
  • Wednesday, May 23 2012 6:17 PM EDT2012-05-23 22:17:22 GMT
    Cleveland Mayor Frank Jackson has a plan to erase the district's $65M deficit. Mayor Jackson announced Wednesday that Ohio's House and Senate are expected to vote Thursday on the legislature needed to
    Cleveland Mayor Frank Jackson has a plan to erase the district's $65M deficit.
  • Wednesday, May 23 2012 3:04 PM EDT2012-05-23 19:04:04 GMT
    John Caputo - Eastlake Police photo
    A suspected serial bank robber struck again Saturday, this time at Eastlake's Dollar bank. According to Eastlake Police, Dollar Bank located at 34829 Vine Street was robbed around 9:30 a.m. by the individual
    A suspected serial bank robber has surrendered to Eastlake Police.
  • Wednesday, May 23 2012 3:00 PM EDT2012-05-23 19:00:54 GMT
    Sentencing is set for this afternoon for Zachary Brody. The 27-year-old Bowling Green man has already pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter and tampering with evidence in the death of Phil Masterson.
    Zachary Brody has been sentenced to 16 years behind bars.

    The 27-year-old Bowling Green man received the maximum sentence for killing Phil Masterson of Westlake.
  • Wednesday, May 23 2012 2:45 PM EDT2012-05-23 18:45:43 GMT
    A police chase ends in a crash on the highway. It happened around 1:30 p.m. on I-71 northbound near West 130th. Middleburg Heights officers were apparently chasing a woman on a yellow motorcycle, when

    Middleburg Heights Police Officers arrest a 21-year-old man they say led them on a high speed police chase, that ended in a crash. The chase began around 1pm Tuesday, when an officer saw a motorcycle speeding in the high speed lane of I-71.